Investigation and Selection of the Most Efficient Method of Citizenship Education for Household Waste Source Separation Based on the KHAN-FAHP Model

Document Type : Research Article


Payam-e-Noor University, Iran


The learning system provided by the municipalities is one of the most important motivating factors make citizens to participate in urban management plans such as source separation of wastes. In the past years, Tehran municipality has been focusing on providing different training in waste management and specifically source separation, which has not been able to attract public participation. The aim of this paper is to study the failure causes of learning systems and to address the shortcomings in the form of distance learning to provide the most effective learning method. In this regard, the Khan conceptual model has been used in the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process. Finally, the results of the 100 paired comparison questionnaires in this study, which were obtained using Khan's conceptual model and fuzzy theory, introduced mobile applications as the best method of distance learning. The strengths and reasons for its selection, which were obtained from interviews conducted by residents of district 16 of Tehran municipality, are described. To compare between different types of distance learning methods, 8 criteria were used in 25 proposed subcategories categorized by Khan's conceptual model that could integrate the concepts and basis of a standardized and successful distance education system into a fuzzy decision model.


Abbasikasani, H., Haji Zeynalgabedini, M. and Raisi, A. (2018). Pathology of University of Medical Sciences E-learning System based on Khan Model. The Journal of Medical Education and Development, 12(4): 227-239.
Abedi, S., Saeidpour, B., Seyf, M.H. and Farajollahi, M. (2017). The Structural Model of Relationships of the Epistemological Beliefs and Self-Regulatory Learning Strategies: The Mediating Role of Educational Self-efficacy and Achievement Goals.  Quarterly Journal of New Approach In Educational Administration, 8(3): 211-238.
Akhavan Limoodehi, F., Tayefeh, S.M., Heidar, R. and Abdoli, M. (2017). Life Cycle Assessment of Municipal Solid Waste Management in Tehran. Environmental Energy and Economic Research. 1(2):207-218. 
Amini, E., Baniasadi, M., Vahidi, H., Nematollahi, H., Khatami, M., Amandadi, M. et al. 2018.) Affecting Factors of Knowledge-Based Companies Using Fuzzy AHP Model, Case Study Tehran University Enterprise Park. Journal of the Knowledge Economy, 1-19.‏
Amini, E., Nematollahi, H. and Moradi, N. (2017). Estimation and Modeling of Biogas Production in Rural Small Landfills (Case Study: Chaharmahaal and Bakhtiari and Yazd Rural Areas). Environmental Energy and Economic Research, 1(4): 383-392.‏
Ansari, M., Youshanlouei, H.R., and Mood, M.M. (2012). A Conceptual model for success in implementing knowledge management: A case study in Tehran municipality. Journal of Service Science and Management, 5(02): 212-222.
Azizi, S.M., Farajollahi, M., Seraji, F. and Sarmadi, M.R. (2017). Synthesis Research on the Effectiveness of E-Learning in Medical Sciences Education and Its Design and Implementation Requirements. Iranian Journal of Medical Education, 17: 270-287.
Baratian, M., Farajollahi, M., Sarmadi, M.R. (2018). Assessment of Electronic Education Student’s Perception of Effective Distance Education Components to Explain Satisfaction of Electronic Education". Interdisciplinary Journal of Virtual Learning in Medical Sciences, 9(1). (In Press).
Bouhnik, D. and Marcus, T. (2006). Interaction in distanceā€learning courses". Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 57(3): 299-305.
Fattahi, R. and Khalilzadeh, M. (2018). Risk evaluation using a novel hybrid method based on FMEA, extended MULTIMOORA, and AHP methods under fuzzy environment. Safety Science, 102: 290-300.
Ghazban, F., Vahidi, H., Tayefeh, S.M., Ahmadzadeh, A. and Mosavi, S.V. (2014). Assessing The Solid Waste Management System In The Industrial State of Charmshahr & Salariyeh by Using AHP & TBL.  Amirkabir Journal of Civil Engineering, 46(1): 21-22.
Giusti, L. (2009). A review of waste management practices and their impact on human health. Waste management, 29(8): 2227-2239.
Goepel, K.D. (2013). Implementing the analytic hierarchy process as a standard method for multi-criteria decision making in corporate enterprises–a new AHP excel template with multiple inputs. in Proceedings of the international symposium on the analytic hierarchy process. Creative Decisions Foundation Kuala Lumpur.
Hrastinski, S. (2006). Introducing an informal synchronous medium in a distance learning course: how is participation affected?. The Internet and Higher Education, 9(2): 117-131.
ICS, Results of the 1395 census of the Iranian Center for Statistics. (2016), Iranian Center for Statistics.
Kerawalla, L., Minocha, S., Kirkup, G. and Conole, G. (2008). Characterising the different blogging behaviours of students on an online distance learning course. Learning, Media and Technology, 33(1): 21-33.
Khan, B.H. (2005). Managing e-learning: Design, delivery, implementation, and evaluation. IGI Global.
Khetriwal, D.S., Kraeuchi, P., and Widmer, R. (2009). Producer responsibility for e-waste management: key issues for consideration–learning from the Swiss experience". Journal of environmental management, 90(1): 153-165.
Liu, H.C., Fan, X.J., Li, P. and Chen, Y.Z. (2014). Evaluating the risk of failure modes with extended MULTIMOORA method under fuzzy environment. Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence, 34: 168-177.
Naveed, Q.N., Qureshi, M.R.N., Als, A.O., Muhammad, A., Sanober, S. and Shah, A. (2017). Prioritizing barriers of E-Learning for effective teaching-learning using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process (FAHP). in Engineering Technologies and Applied Sciences (ICETAS), 4th IEEE International Conference.
Noori, R., Abdoli, M., Farokhnia, A., and Ghaemi, A. (2009). Solid waste generation predicting by hybrid of artificial neural network and wavelet transform. Journal of Environmental Studies, 35(49): 25-30.
Padash, A., Bidhendi, G. N., Hoveidi, H., and Ardestani, M. (2015). Green strategy management framework towards sustainable development. Bulgarian Chemical Communications, 47, 259-268.
Padash, A., Jozi, S. A., Nabavi, S. M. B., and Dehzad, B. (2016). Stepwise strategic environmental management in marine protected area. Global Journal of Environmental Science and Management, 2(1), 49-60.
Padash, A. (2017). Modeling of Environmental Impact Assessment Based on RIAM and TOPSIS for Desalination and Operating Units. Environmental Energy and Economic Research, 1(1), 75-88.
Perreault, H., Woldman, L., Alexander, M., and Zhao, J. (2002). Overcoming barriers to successful delivery of distance-learning courses. Journal of Education for Business, 77(6): 313-318.
Shams Fallah, F., Vahidi, H., Pazoki, M., Akhavan-Limudehi, F., Aslemand, A.R., and Samiee Zafarghandi, R. (2012). Investigation of solid waste disposal alternatives in Lavan Island using life cycle assessment approach". International Journal of Environmental Research, 7(1): 155-164.
Shee, D.Y. and Wang, Y.S. (2008). Multi-criteria evaluation of the web-based e-learning system: A methodology based on learner satisfaction and its applications. Computers & Education, 50(3): 894-905.
Vahidi, H., Hoveidi, H., Kazemzadeh Khoie, J., Nematollahi, H., and Heydari, R. (2018). Analyzing material flow in Alborz industrial estate, Ghazvin, Iran. Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management, 20(1): 450-460.‏
Vahidi, H., Nematollahi, H., Padash, A., Sadeghi, B., and RiaziNejad, M. (2017). Comparison of Rural Solid Waste Management in Two Central Provinces of Iran. Environmental Energy and Economic Research, 2017. 1: p. 209-220.
Vahidi, H., Ghazban, F., Abdoli, M.A., Dehghani Kazemi, V., Banaei, S.M.A. (2014). Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process Disposal Method Selection for an Industrial State; Case Study Charmshahr. Arabian Journal for Science & Engineering, 39(2): 725-735.
Wang, Y.M., Chin, K.S., Poon, G.K.K., Yang, J.B. (2009). Risk evaluation in failure mode and effects analysis using fuzzy weighted geometric mean. Expert systems with applications, 36(2): 1195-1207.
Widmer, R., Oswald-Krapf, H., Sinha-Khetriwal, D., Schnellmann, M., and Boni, H. (2005). Global perspectives on e-waste. Environmental impact assessment review, 25(5): 436-458.
Zadeh, L.A. (1976). A fuzzy-algorithmic approach to the definition of complex or imprecise concepts. International Journal of Man-Machine Studies, 8(3): 202-282.